Consider distributing or adapting the following handout to share with students to encourage effective peer-review strategies: remember that readers' opinions may differ and that you're ultimately responsible for your paper the above strategies are most effective when your paper is reviewed by a helpful reader. Read the essay again while reading, note the following for each paragraph of your partner's essay: identify and paraphrase the topic of the paragraph—what it “says” identify what the paragraph does—its purpose and connection to the essay note this in the margins review the outline and identify the structure of the. Literary analysis peer commentary questions (adapted from analyzing literature: a guide for students, by sharon james mcgee) writer's name: reviewer's name: 1 read through the draft once for a first does the author prove his/her point by the end of the essay is this claim reasonable and logical given your. Steps for peer response 1 read aloud students having their papers workshopped will read their papers aloud while their group members listen attentively and follow along on their copies 2 freewrite after the first reading, group members will freewrite their general impressions on the essay in section i, focusing on. Peer evaluation guidelines: could be used for an in-class or a take-home peer review in-class writing group worksheet: though tailored to the argument paper, this worksheet could easily be adapted to other units guidelines for writing peer review letters: basic guidelines for a take-home peer review letter, including a.
This handout first describes general considerations that can help improve the quality of the feedback students offer one another before describing several strategies for this method of peer review works best when students have prepared comments on the paper before class and are ready to discuss the work in detail. B decide when peer-review sessions will occur the ideal time for peer review is after students have written a complete draft of a paper, but while there is still time for substantial revision (see the handout, “peer review: a method for teaching reading, writing, and collaboration skills”) each peer-review session will. Why requiring peer-review sessions • merely one peer-review session could increase the quality of the student's final paper this not only makes reading papers easier, it also saves grading time • requiring peer review guarantees that at least one other person has read through the student's draft furthermore, when. When you are the reader/consultant: ▫ read the paper out loud as it appears do not automatically add in missing words or word endings this will help you and the listener spot these typos ▫ look especially at the organization of the paper ensure that the writer provided enough details in the body paragraphs to make the.
Peer review read through your classmate's paper and then answer the questions below on a separate sheet of paper remember to put your name on the paper so that you can receive credit summary: 1 what is the thesis of the article according to the summary list the main points supporting this thesis as they appear. You are looking at the structure of the essay _____ is the essay free of mistakes with homophones (their, there, they're / too, to, two / your, you're, etc) _____/ 50 pts historical essay 1 _____ / 30 final draft 3 _____/ 5 first draft 4 _____/ 5 completed peer review worksheet 5 _____ / 5 self assessment 6.
Peer editing – rhetorical analysis essay author: reviewed by: please provide specific and constructive feedback you can write on the paper itself and also on this sheet 1) can you identify the thesis statement is it too broad too narrow how could it be improved what do you feel the focus of the rest of the paper. Great writing 4: great essays peer editing sheets peer editing sheet 1 u nit 2, activity 13, page 62 narrative essay outline writer: date: peer editor: topic: 1 is the hook interesting if not, how could it be review the essay for specific information, such as quotes, dates, and statistics did the writer give the source of this. For peer review, you will write comments on your peers' essays in two ways: 1) comments throughout the body of the essay in the form of specific questions of grammar and mla documentation, and 2) a concluding paragraph at the end of the essay (either at the bottom or on a separate sheet of paper) in which you state.
Peer editing sheet paper writer's name 1 talk to the paper writer about any concerns s/he may have about the paper read through the paper fairly quickly to get a sense of the whole thing read primarily to suggestions for revision: try reading your paper out loud (this works especially well if you actually read it to. Peer revision worksheet prof della fera peer review sheet essay writing peer review worksheet what is your overall impression of this essay explain what is this essay's thesis, or main point is there a sentence that functions as the thesis if so, underline it does the introduction capture.